Friday, 8 April 2011

Bringing The Hunch Back

When I look at the advertising being produced these days, I see an awful lot of work that’s been logicked to death – work that’s perfectly clean, simple, efficient and practical but lacks that little spark, that little bit of magic that makes it truly engage.

And I feel a big reason for this is that we’ve lost touch with our instincts. That magical combination of hunch and insight that allows us to produce really cut-through work, rather than the stuff which, in the words of my old Art Director, “sits in a corner and whistles to itself.”

When I ask myself why this is, I have to point to two big culprits:

1) Lack of time

2) Abuse of research

First, lack of time – I know that to an extent, there’s nothing we can do about that. We live in a fast-paced, accelerating world but I do think we have to take stock of some of the good things we may have lost as a result of this. And one of those things is our ability to really engage with our instincts. Consider Madmen’s Don Draper for moment - a guy who spends the majority of the series angstily trying to connect with fresh insights about brands that he can feel in his gut and go in and whack down on a boardroom table with all the power of a strongly felt conviction. I feel it’s our duty, if we’re to be truly creative individuals to allow ourselves pause to get in touch with our instincts about brands, not simply provide clients with bandaid, off-the-peg marketing solutions. And yes that takes a bit of time because instinct can’t be turned on and off like a tap – but I’m convinced that it’s time well spent.

Now onto number 2. Although I think Research in general is a great learning tool, I think that we, as an industry, crossed a line when we stopped using it as a way of backing up our hunches and instead let it become a way of deciding which idea was best. The great campaigns “Happiness is a cigar called Hamlet” and “Heineken refreshes the parts other beers cannot reach” famously bombed in research but the people behind them still had enough courage in their instincts to make sure they ran anyway. I feel as though we’ve gone from there to a point where we’ve now effectively made Melissa from Braintree and her mates in the research group our Creative Directors. Which all too often leads to solutions that are ‘successful’ merely because they have the warm, cosy glow of familiarity.

Instinct is a rare and wonderful thing to behold. It’s seeing a brand like Marmite that’s brave enough to dedicate half of its marketing budget to demonstrate how much people hate their product. Or watching a TV commercial that ends with the random but utterly memorable declaration “I’m on a horse”.

But there is ultimately one compelling reason for us to make sure we’re connecting with our gut feelings in this industry, and it’s this – if we can’t trust our own instincts about our work, how on earth can we expect our clients to?

No comments:

Post a Comment